Business Meeting Minutes
October 24, 1998


National Association of Industrial Technology
1998 Annual Business Meeting Minutes
Saturday, October 24, 1998

8:00 a.m.

I. Opening Remarks: Mr. John Reese, Chair, Executive Board, welcomed the membership and thanked them for their participation in the conference and in the Association.

II. Review and Approval of the Minutes of the October 11, 1997 Annual Business Meeting: A motion was made from the floor to approve the minutes of the 1997 Annual Business Meeting. The motion was supported and was approved on a voice vote by the majority of those present.

III. Executive Board Report: Mr. Reese gave a brief report.

IV. National Office Reports: Executive Director Dr. Alvin E. Rudisill gave a brief report.

A. Finance: Dr. Rudisill noted that the year end financial balance for 1998 is lower than in past years, having declined from highs in the mid-$80,000 range in 1993, 1994, and 1995, dropping to $57,707 in 1997, ending the 1998 year at $51,058. This provides some basis for concern, particularly with respect to national accreditation recognition, though NAIT is extremely stable from an administrative standpoint. On the positive side, various initiatives are underway which will favorably affect the financial base, such as a revised accreditation visit fee and expense structure, establishment of accreditation program sponsorships, and establishment of the NAIT Foundation.

B. Membership: There was a slight decrease in membership, from 1960 to 1955 over the past year, but a significant increase in Student Division memberships masks the more significant declines in other divisions. Dr. Rudisill noted that Division officers have committed to increased new membership outreach and that the national office will become more involved in a membership marketing effort. Dr. Rudisill also noted that NAIT has a very low membership fee in comparison to similar professional organizations.

C. Association Initiatives: Dr. Rudisill reported that SME will be the first accreditation program sponsor, in the area of Manufacturing, which should yield a net annual gain of approximately $10,000 for NAIT. Pursuant to action at the May 1998 Executive Board meeting and the affirmative vote on by-laws changes, a NAIT Foundation has been established with Dr. Clois Kicklighter as its first Chair. The Executive Board has approved the Foundation Handbook at its meeting on October 21, 1998. The conference continues its evolution toward an emphasis on focus groups and presentation tracks in focus group areas. The focus group emphasis has led to significant movement toward the establishment of new, more technically focused divisions which should prove more meaningful to members and provide better understanding and recognition to NAIT and its accreditation and certification programs in the industrial community. Three focus groups have met the prerequisites in the NAIT Bylaws for establishment as new divisions, an item that will be the subject of action later in the Business Meeting. The NAIT Public Relations program has moved forward in its first major project, the Industrial Technology Career Opportunities CD-ROM project, on which Dr. Brauer will report.

D. Publications: Dr. Rudisill noted that the new 1998-1999 Associate Program Directory has been published and that the 1999 Baccalaureate Directory is nearing its publication date. The Journal of Industrial Technology's 56th issue is at the printer and the Executive Board will be considering a proposal to move the JIT to an electronic, on-line format, accessible through the NAIT WebPage. General reaction to the proposal has been favorable due to the increased access the on-line JIT will provide and due to the large cost savings that will result, savings that can be redirected toward new membership-oriented publications.

E. NAIT Home Page: The NAIT website is growing and generating a lot of traffic. In addition to Association, Division, Accreditation and Certification information, the website is a tool for communicating with the national office and linking to other IT-related sites. The JIT will soon appear on the NAIT website, complete with an author and key word search system, making the JIT a more useful research tool than the current published version. Advertisers have also reported that the WebPage ads are effective, garnering responses from all over the country.

V. Special Committee and Board Reports:

A. Board of Accreditation: Dr. Everett Israel, Chair of the Board of Accreditation, reported that the Board of Accreditation conducted 26 hearings during the conference. There were five first time accreditation hearings at the baccalaureate level, eleven re-accreditation hearings (2 Associate; 9 Baccalaureate); and 10 status report hearings -- the largest number of hearings at one conference since the founding of NAIT. The decisions made by the Board increased the number of institutions with NAIT accreditation from 53 to 57 (two institutions have associate and baccalaureate level programs accredited by NAIT. The number of programs accredited increased from 104 to 110 and the number of programs and options increased from 235 to 257.

Dr. Israel complemented the Visiting Team Chairpersons for the quality of their reports, which allowed the Board members to focus on major topics and take efficient action, which reduced the time needed to conduct the hearings.

The Board of Accreditation formed a task force to develop and implement accreditation standards for Industrial Technology Masters Degree programs. The members of the task force are Dr. Donald Bennion, Chairperson, Dr. Lowell Anderson, Dr. James DeLaura, Dr. Mohammed Fahmy, Dr. Jerry Parish, and Dr. Randall Shaw.

NAIT has been asked to participate in the SME Manufacturing Accreditation Workshop to be held in September 1999. Tentative plans are for NAIT to hold Team Training and Preparation of Self-Study reports and to give an orientation to NAIT accreditation.

B. Standards and Accreditation: Dr. John Sutton and Mr. Harold Finn reported that the Standards and Accreditation Committee held an all day training session for team members and team chairs at the convention, led by Dr. Brad Lawson and assisted by Mr. Finn. Fifteen NAIT members attended the session -- eight previous attendees and seven attendees receiving training for the first time. The committee recommended that the Board of Accreditation approve the seven who received initial training along with one CCTI member who has been very active in the NAIT accreditation, having led the development of the self-study at his institution for both initial and reaccreditation. The Board of Accreditation approved all of these. Additionally, three Industry Division Members were approved as team members upon the recommendation of an accredited institution.

The Standards and Accreditation Committee conducted a hearing to discuss the merit of changes to 14 of the accreditation standards (the substance of the standards affected and the discussion can be found on the NAIT web page.) The committee submitted these standards to the Board of Accreditation for public review and action.

C. Board of Certification: Dr. Rudisill reported there has continued to be a decline in certifications, from highs of over 800 reached in 1993 and 1994, with declines in each division particularly the Industry Division. Dr. Rudisill noted that a major problem is the decline due to initial certifications not being renewed. Promoting the meaning and value of certification, within the association and its divisions and within the industrial community, presents a challenge for the Executive Board, the Board of Certification, and the membership and Dr. Rudisill pledged strong national office involvement in this issue.

D. Foundation Board: Dr. Clois Kicklighter reported that the NAIT Foundation has been formally approved and that he is pleased to have been appointed as its first Board chair. The new board has gone to work, while the process of identifying new board members will continue. In addition to Dr. Kicklighter, also serving are Dr. Rudisill, Dr. Mark Estepp, Mr. Hank Martin, Dr. Raj Chowdhury and Dr. John Earshen. The Board has met three times during the conference and Board positions continue to be filled. Foundation Boards tend to be large, "working" boards in which membership is extended to individuals with strong fundraising abilities, personal commitment to the goals of the foundation, or on the basis of personal contributions.

Those interested in serving on the Foundation Board should inform Dr. Kicklighter. Dr. Kicklighter appealed to the membership to recommend individuals to be solicited for Foundation Board membership or contributions, particularly retired NAIT members who may be in the best position to contribute their time and resources to the success of the Foundation.

A NAIT Foundation WebPage is being developed for addition to the NAIT website and a committee is working on a NAIT foundation promotional brochure. The Board has identified two campaigns related to "charter memberships" - one directed at individuals and one directed at organizations. The Foundation Board has set their next meeting date to be consistent with the Spring Executive Board meeting in Florida.

E. Public Relations Committee: Dr. William Brauer reported on the development of the NAIT IT Career Opportunities CD-ROM that will be directed at high school students through a pilot project. The committee is also developing an industry-directed newsletter and an industry database as a means of gaining recognition and finding new members within industry.

VI. Division Reports:

A. Community College and Technical Institute: Mr. Edward McGarry reported that the CCTI Division had a 12% decline in membership, despite efforts to increase and retain membership. Two schools were reaccredited and the CCTI Division is working on gathering criteria from industry for the development of a certification exam.

B. Student: Dr. C. Ray Diez reported that Student Division membership has continued to increase. The Division is working on the problem of membership non-renewal subsequent to graduation with efforts to improve the transfer of students from the Student Division to the Industry Division as they move into their careers. The Division is also working on the retention of certification after graduation, noting that there is significant student interest in a testing requirement for initial certification and in involving students in the Boards of Accreditation and Certification. The Student Division has used its conference meetings to plan a student program for the 1999 conference and have established 7 committees for the next year.

C. University: Dr. Ming Land reported that Dr. Jerry Parish of Texas A&M University-Commerce will be the next division President and that Dr. Art Rosser of Central Missouri State University has been elected president-elect of the division.

Dr. Land reported that he had placed a great deal of emphasis on membership recruitment and member involvement, personally contacting potential members throughout the world and urging fellow industrial technology faculty to join NAIT. In spite of the Division's efforts, membership showed a small decline during the past year.

He noted there should be opportunities for each and every member to be involved meaningfully in the organizational direction of NAIT and the activities at the annual convention. The first two of such opportunities were in the activities of the Focus Groups and the establishment of three proposed divisions -- Manufacturing, Graphic Communications, and Research. Another opportunity will be for members to participate in the NAIT Foundation. Two members from the University Division, Dr. Mark Estepp of Appalachian State University and Dr. Raj Chowdhury of Kent State University, will serve on the Foundation Board. The Division supports the public relations initiative that is currently being undertaken by Dr. Brauer at Bemidji State University in Minnesota. The University Division is in favor of the electronic publishing of the Journal of Industrial Technology and the publication of the Baccalaureate Degree Program Directory in a joint effort with the Council on Technology Education (CTTE) and the National Association of Industrial and Technical Teacher Educators (NAITTE). The University Division supports the accreditation of colleges and universities and the standards for accreditation.

Dr. Land noted that the University Division was well represented at the convention, with the majority of the paper presentations and the focus groups activities from the division members. The Division is proud of its contributions to NAIT and the active participation of its members in the convention.

D. Industry: Mr. John Reese reported that the Outstanding Industrial Technologist award has continued and is on a firm financial footing for at least the next year, but that a permanent funding structure needs to be developed. He suggested that more formal recognition of past OIT award winners be incorporated into future conference programs, as a form of acknowledgement and as a means of using their experience and expertise for the education of members and to help foster stronger connections to NAIT within industry.

He reported the continued struggle of the Industry Division with retention of membership, which makes effective functioning of the division difficult. He noted that the underlying issue is the larger organizational need to increase the importance of NAIT certification within the industrial community.

VII. Old Business: No items of old business were raised for discussion.

VIII. New Business:

A. Approval of New Divisions: A motion was made from the floor to recommend that the Executive Board approve the establishment of "Special Divisions" in 1) Manufacturing Systems, 2) Graphic Communications, and 3) Research and that the development of other special divisions be encouraged and approved. Further, that for a two-year period the Executive Board allows membership in one "Professional Standing Division" plus one "Special Division" for the single division membership fee. The motion was supported.

Discussion ensued. Concerns were registered about the impact of new divisions on membership in standing divisions, and the membership fee aspect of the motion was explained as an effort to minimize immediate negative impacts. It was also noted that the Focus Groups proposing the new divisions have met the prerequisites in the Bylaws for the formation of new divisions. It was noted that additional divisions need not adopt the same structure as existing standing divisions and that to the extent new organizational issues are presented by the addition of divisions the Board and membership will need to discuss and resolve them.

An amendment was offered from the floor to replace the words "special divisions" in the motion with the words "special interest groups." The amendment was supported. Discussion of the proposed amendment ensued. A motion was made to call the question. The motion was supported. The question was called. A majority voting against rejected the amendment on a voice vote.

A motion was made to call the main question and the motion was supported. The question was called. A majority voting in favor approved the main motion on a voice vote.

IX. Report on 1999 Annual Conference: Dr. Rudisill reported that attendance at the 1998 NAIT Annual Conference was up significantly, which may be due to the variety of registration options that were established by the Board. The number of presentations was also up and the organization of presentations on technical lines continues to be well received. Focus group meetings have been productive, with three new divisions being organized and others still under development.

X. Installation of Officers: Dr. Rudisill introduced the new division officers for 1998-1999: John Sollman, President, CCTI Division;; John Reese, President, Industry Division; Matthew P. Stephens, President, Student Division; and Dr. Jerry Parish, President, University Division. Dr. Rudisill also recognized the outgoing division presidents, Ed McGarry, Past President, CCTI Division; Dr. C. Ray Diez, Past President, Student Division; Dr. Ming Land, Past President, University Division; and Executive Board Chair, John W. Reese. Dr. Kicklighter presented the outgoing officers with a plaque of recognition and appreciation from NAIT for their service.

XI. Closing Remarks: Executive Board Chair John Reese made brief closing comments and thanked all of those present for their participation in the Business Meeting and the Conference.

A motion was made from the floor to adjourn the Annual Business Meeting. The motion was supported. A majority voting in favor approved the motion on a voice vote.

The Annual Business Meeting was adjourned at 10:20 a.m.